Home / secrets

Pinkie Promise Secrets

Updated 2026-10-28. This page answers: Find the hidden interactions players call secrets, and how strong the evidence is for each.

No official secret total was found in the reviewed sources. The community list below names ten interactions, including the official Say Cheese badge. This is a collected list, not a studio-confirmed total or a complete Scrapbook checklist.

Evidence and limits

The named interactions are reported by pinkiepromiseguide. Official badge descriptions confirm some names, but do not confirm their precise triggers. No timestamped video check of every interaction is documented here. Say Cheese location and the Creature of Habit condition remain single-source or unknown.

Named interactions

Secrets can be triggered again on a new run. They are not a one-time save flag, according to pinkiepromiseguide. The private room is three steps: key on the dresser, open the door, look at the recipe and the photos.

Community reports, not independently confirmed triggers. Source: pinkiepromiseguide secrets page, checked 28 October 2026.
Secret	Where	What to do	Evidence
Somepony at the Window	Barn loft	Ask Applejack about the loft window	Single written trigger source; badge name is official
Angry Applejack	Barn fire	Throw the fire water on Applejack	Single written trigger source; badge name is official
Somepony on the Train	Carriage	Check the marked window	Single written trigger source; badge name is official
Not Fire!	Vines	Use a flame instead of a glowcap	Single written trigger source; badge name is official
Spin Cycle	Gummy	Walk up and interact	Community report; no documented video timestamp
Wrong Answer	Promise talk	Refuse the promise repeatedly	Community report; no documented video timestamp
Broken Promise	After you agree	Try to leave	Single written trigger source; badge name is official
I Dare You	Party table	Poke Pinkie before you sit	Community report; no documented video timestamp
Creature of Habit	Bakery search	Hide in the same cupboard every time	One source only
Say Cheese	Exact location unverified	Photo-related badge; exact interaction point unknown	Official badge name and description only

Do not read this table as “there are exactly 10 secrets.” That total is the community map.

Thumbnail from Josh Plays’ secrets and badges video — Frame: Josh Plays, uploaded 19 October 2026.

Official kitchen thumbnail where several party secrets happen — Image: Roblox / Party Cannon Studios.

Josh Plays: PINKIE PROMISE: All Secrets & Badges - Roblox — supplementary Chapter 1 footage.

Questions

Can you miss a secret forever?

The guide site says a new session can pick them up again. The badge API does not say otherwise.

Keep reading

Pinkie Promise Hiding spots · Pinkie Promise Badges · Pinkie Promise Endings · Pinkie Promise Walkthrough

Sources

pinkiepromiseguide secrets — reviewed 2026-10-28
pinkie-promise.wiki — reviewed 2026-10-28
Roblox badges API — reviewed 2026-10-28
Josh Plays: PINKIE PROMISE: All Secrets & Badges - Roblox — video upload metadata: 2026-10-19T17:40:54-07:00. Supplementary viewing; timestamps for individual claims are not documented.